The General is one of the few carriers that will write FR-44 policies, but their rates and coverage options may not be your best long-term fit. Here's how to evaluate your options mid-compliance without triggering a lapse.
Why The General Writes FR-44 Policies When Most Carriers Won't
The General operates in the non-standard auto insurance market, serving drivers with DUI convictions, suspended licenses, and other high-risk profiles that standard carriers like State Farm and Geico typically decline or non-renew. They file FR-44 certificates in Virginia because their underwriting model accounts for elevated risk, and they price accordingly.
Your initial premium with The General likely ranged from $150 to $350 per month for Virginia's required 50/100/40 liability minimums with FR-44 filing. That rate reflects both your DUI conviction and The General's position as a non-standard carrier willing to accept compliance-mandated business.
The trade-off: you got coverage when few other carriers would write you, but you're paying non-standard market rates. As you move through your 3-year compliance period, other non-standard carriers—Bristol West, Dairyland, Direct Auto, Safe Auto—become accessible for comparison. The General isn't necessarily your only option for the full three years.
When First-Renewal Rate Increases Signal It's Time to Shop
Non-standard carriers frequently use introductory pricing to acquire FR-44 customers, then increase premiums at the first renewal. Rate jumps of 25-40% are common across the non-standard market, not unique to The General.
If your six-month renewal notice shows a premium increase from $900 to $1,260 for identical coverage, that's a $360 annual increase with no change in your driving record or claims history. Under current Virginia regulations, carriers must provide notice of renewal premium changes, but they're not required to justify the increase beyond general underwriting updates.
This is the moment most FR-44 drivers start comparison shopping. You're no longer desperate for any coverage—you've demonstrated 6-12 months of compliance, continuous coverage, and (ideally) clean driving during that period. That compliance history makes you a more attractive risk to competing non-standard carriers.
Get FR-44 insurance quotes from carriers that file in Florida and Virginia
FR-44 requires higher liability limits than SR-22 — compare carriers that understand the difference.
Get Your Free Quote✓ FR-44 Filing Included✓ No Obligation✓ Licensed Carriers✓ FL & VA Specialists
How to Switch FR-44 Carriers Without Creating a Filing Gap
Virginia uses the SR-26 form to notify the DMV when your FR-44 coverage lapses or cancels. Any gap in FR-44 filing—even one day—resets your 3-year compliance clock to day zero. Switching carriers requires coordinated effective dates.
Start shopping 30-45 days before your current policy renewal date. When you bind a new policy with a different carrier, specify an effective date that matches or precedes your current policy's expiration date. The new carrier files your FR-44 certificate with the Virginia DMV before the new policy starts.
The General will file an SR-26 notice when your policy cancels, but if your new carrier's FR-44 is already on file with an overlapping or immediately consecutive effective date, the DMV sees continuous coverage. No gap means no compliance reset. Confirm with your new carrier that they will file the FR-44 before your coverage starts—some carriers file same-day, others require 3-5 business days.
Which Non-Standard Carriers Accept Mid-Compliance Transfers
Bristol West, Dairyland, Direct Auto, and Safe Auto all write FR-44 policies in Virginia and accept transfers from other non-standard carriers mid-compliance. Acceptance, GAINSCO, and Mendota also operate in the Virginia non-standard market but availability varies by ZIP code.
Your eligibility depends on your current driving record during the compliance period. If you've added a second DUI, an at-fault accident with injury, or multiple moving violations since starting FR-44, your options narrow significantly. Most non-standard carriers will decline transfers if you've accumulated two or more major violations during active FR-44 filing.
Request quotes from at least three carriers. Monthly premiums can vary by $50-$150 for identical coverage and FR-44 filing, driven by each carrier's proprietary risk models and their current appetite for FR-44 business in your county. Direct Auto may quote $180/month while Dairyland quotes $240/month for the same driver profile and coverage limits.
What Happens to Your Compliance Clock When You Switch
Your 3-year FR-44 compliance period in Virginia runs from your conviction date, not your filing date or policy effective date. Switching carriers does not restart or extend that period as long as you maintain continuous FR-44 coverage with no gaps.
The Virginia DMV tracks your compliance by monitoring FR-44 filings submitted by your current carrier. When you switch from The General to another carrier, the DMV receives the SR-26 cancellation notice from The General and the new FR-44 certificate from your new carrier. As long as the dates align without gaps, your compliance clock continues uninterrupted.
You can verify your compliance status and remaining time by requesting your driving record from the Virginia DMV. The record will show your FR-44 start date and the calculated end date three years later. Most drivers check this 60-90 days before their anticipated completion date to confirm the DMV's records match their own calculation.
Coverage Adjustments to Consider When Switching Carriers
Virginia requires only 50/100/40 liability coverage for FR-44 compliance—$50,000 bodily injury per person, $100,000 per accident, $40,000 property damage. Those minimums leave significant gaps if you cause a serious accident.
When you're already paying non-standard rates, increasing to 100/300/100 liability limits typically adds $20-$40 per month. That higher limit protects your assets if you're found at-fault in an accident that exceeds the state minimums. Medical costs from even a moderate injury accident can exceed $50,000.
Some non-standard carriers offer uninsured motorist coverage as an optional add-on for FR-44 policies. This coverage protects you if you're hit by a driver with no insurance or insufficient limits. Virginia doesn't require UM coverage for FR-44 compliance, but approximately 12-15% of Virginia drivers are uninsured according to Insurance Information Institute data, making this gap coverage worth evaluating during a carrier switch.
Cost Comparison: Staying vs. Switching After Year One
Assume your initial General FR-44 policy cost $1,800 for six months ($300/month). At first renewal, the premium increases to $2,400 for six months ($400/month)—a 33% increase. Over the remaining two years of compliance, staying with The General at the increased rate costs $9,600.
If you switch to Dairyland at $340/month for the same coverage and limits, your remaining two-year cost is $8,160. The savings: $1,440 over two years, minus any policy fees for the new carrier (typically $50-$75). Even accounting for the time required to shop and switch, that's a $1,365 net savings for roughly three hours of comparison work.
These figures assume stable rates with the new carrier, which isn't guaranteed in the non-standard market. Ask each quoting carrier about their renewal rate history for FR-44 policies. Some carriers offer rate reduction programs for FR-44 customers who complete defensive driving courses or maintain 12 months of claims-free driving during compliance.
